This man fell at work. What’s the fallout?

This 53-year-old male has left knee pain since a fall at work. You are shown proton density (image 1) and proton density with fat-suppression (image 2) images with abnormality labeled (green arrow).

Q1 – What is the most likely diagnosis?

Q2 – What is the typical mechanism of injury?

Q3 – What is the treatment plan?

Sagittal PD

Sagittal PD


A1 – The diagnosis is posterior cruciate ligament (PCL) avulsion fracture with typical pretibial abrasion from impaction with the knee in flexion as mechanism of injury.

A2 – Typical mechanism of injury is a blow to the knee in flexion (“dashboard or aviator injury”), usually with contusion of the anterior prepatellar soft tissues (pink / purple arrows).

A3 – Most posterior cruciate ligament tears are not surgically treated. Surgical treatment is indicated if there is fragment displacement, diastasis or an accompanying posterolateral corner injury so as to prevent posterolateral rotary instability (PLRI), or posterolateral recurrent instability syndrome. Sometimes, with a posteromedial corner semimembranosus injury, the PCL may also have to be repaired.

Typically, tears of the PCL itself do not produce retraction, separation or gapping of the PCL fibers. Rather, there is bleeding and interstitial injury of the ligament even though functionally the ligament is no longer a source of tibial stability and restraint.

However, when there is a fracture at the PCL attachment to the tibia in the PCL notch, surgery may be indicated.

(a) The choices are immobilization or casting if the fragment is close to the main bone. This might help precipitate a union.
(b) On the other hand, if there is a substantive gap, rotation, or angulation, the fragment may require repositioning and external fixation from a posterior approach.


Check out MRI Online for more case review.

If you enjoyed this case, you may also enjoy:

What can be learned from this 17-year-old’s knee injury?
What type of tear is causing this 20-year-old athlete’s knee pain?
How should you approach this 24-year-old’s knee case?


Newsletter Signup